Re: late entry into Lynn and Stephen's conversation


[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Skeptics Society Message Board ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by Lynn on January 01, 1997 at 12:29:27:

In Reply to: late entry into Lynn and Stephen's conversation posted by Chris Woolston on December 30, 1996 at 11:14:04:

: I'd like to make a late entry into the conversation
: between Lynn and Stephen regarding the origins of the
: universe and evolution. Lynn asked several times for
: an explanation of how an orderly universe could arise
: from the chaos after the big bang. True, a universe
: full of aimless particles and lawless energy would never
: produce order "of itself." But the gases and energy of
: the early universe had to answer to the laws of physics.
: Cosmologists don't know exactly how gravity and
: quantum mechanics formed the stars and the planets
: and the pulsars -- but none doubts that it happened.


Forgive me for beating a dead horse, but how did gravity and quantum physics come to be?

: As for evolution, Lynn says she doesn't know of any case
: where a mutation actually helped an organism. In her
: opinion, any adaptations are merely a case of recessive
: genes rising to dominance. Let's examine the case of
: Adam and Eve, the first humans. As depicted by the
: Christians, the first humans were white humans. White
: skin is clearly adaptive for people living in Europe.
: But the descendants of Adam and Eve that migrated to
: Africa developed dark skin, a very effective defense
: against skin cancer. Did Adam and Eve carry
: unexpressed recessive genes for dark skin? If so, one
: in four of their children would have been dark-skinned.

: If Adam and Eve were the first humans, a genetic
: mutation must have crept into their bloodline, giving
: rise to a race of people well-equipped to live in the
: tropics. By the way, I happen to think that the story
: worked the other way around, that the first humans had
: dark skin and a mutation gave rise to a race of people
: that could thrive in Northern Europe. But the point
: remains the same.

I was unaware that christians professed the first humans to be white. There is absolutely no way of knowing. I believe Adam and Eve must have carried all the genes necessary to breed every race. If this is scientifically IMpossible, I would appreciate it if you would clear me up.
: Many mutations are meaningless, some are lethal, but
: some mutations are clearly beneficial. The short-necked
: ancestors of giraffes did not have recessive genes for
: extremely long necks. Mutations that made the neck
: incrementally longer tended to get passed on to future
: generations until modern giraffes could reach the very
: tops of the trees. Penicillin used to be extremely
: lethal to infectious bacteria, but mutations made many
: strains of bacteria resistant to antibiotics. The
: examples of beneficial mutations are endless.

I wasn't aware that developing resistance to something was the equivalent of a mutation. Also, I wonder how you know that giraffes didn't carry the gene for a long neck.
: Sorry I entered this discussion so late. I only
: discovered this site a few days ago. Looks like a
: great place to hold a conversation. Happy remainder of
: the holidays.





Follow Ups:



Post a Followup

Name:
E-Mail:

Subject:

Comments:

Optional Link URL:
Link Title:
Optional Image URL:


[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Skeptics Society Message Board ] [ FAQ ]